Collateral Damage
Part of the Series: Unnatural Causes

California Newsreel
Show More

Comments (44)

Anonymous picture
Alayna

This is my first time learning about the Marshall islands, and it seems to follow the trend of Americans and other nations using a nation for its resources or experimentation, but then not offering enough or any compensation for the lives they've impacted. This is very frustrating, and I ...Read more

Anonymous picture
Rochelle

I am very disappointed in the United States and how we handled the situation in the Marshall Islands. They didn't have to suffer the way that they did and it sickens me that they suffered because of the United States. I feel bad for them that they live in such close quarters and almost all ...Read more

Anonymous picture
Aleksei

This video really made me more disappointed than anything else, specifically disappointed in how we handled the situation. The people in these communities are just that-people! These communities are suffering major consequences to this day from our choices! So sad.

Anonymous picture
Eric

After watching this I am very disappointed with the way we handled things in the Marshall Islands. After we made a mistake and infecting people we chose just to use them as tests for scientific discovery instead of helping them to the best of our ability.

Anonymous picture
Anna

It is amazing to think of the impact of decisions made years ago are still impacting people today. The poverty and desperation for jobs lead people to their ultimate demise and poor health.

Anonymous picture
Kristen

This video was also hard for me to watch as it was really sad to see what these communities were going through. I also completely agree that since we made them move, that we should help them so that they do not have suffer like this. These horrible conditions and poverty lead to an increase ...Read more

Anonymous picture
Justin

The level of poverty is some of these places saddens me. Poverty leads to an increase in disease and it would be tough for these people to prevent TB. Our country I feel should help these people out a little bit and try to provide vaccines to try and prevent TB in lots of people.

Anonymous picture
Tori

I did not know about these islands until watching this video. I feel like the United States should be more willing to help these people since our military were the ones who made them leave their homes and island. They more than likely would not have had as many health issues if we did not add ...Read more

Anonymous picture
Jeanna

All policies somehow become a health policy. If there are no policies in place for your community you are more likely to have an unhealthy community. This video was hard to watch due to the things that these communities go through. Although they are no longer part of the United States, they ...Read more

Anonymous picture
Hayley

I was not aware of the Marshall Islands until I watched this video and it really opened my eyes. Our government should be more willing to help these people. We should also be thinking about how our actions have long term affects that we do not think about at the time of making decisions.

Anonymous picture
Lydia

It's hard to know that your own country contributed to the unhealthiness of the Marshall Islands and Kwajalein and the fall of their culture. We still see an inequality of the indigenous people there and the Americans that inhabit the islands. If we are inhabiting their land, you would think ...Read more

Anonymous picture
Jelena

This video was very eye opening to me because I was not aware of such disasters in the Marshall Islands. It is extremely devastating that the tuberculosis rate is a shocking 23 times higher than in the United States.

Anonymous picture
Richard

What a mess the United States created in the Marshall Islands. I hope that in the future the US can be more cautious about the impacts of using other lands for our benefit. The nuclear testing not only directly impacted the health of the Marshallese, but it uprooted the entire culture.

Anonymous picture
jensen

The Marshall Islanders did not stand a chance when put up against the nuclear fall out and then being sent to an area of poverty and no sanitation. It is unfortunate that people are forced to find a way of life with these circumstances.

Anonymous picture
Melinda

I do not understand why our government refuses to help these people. It is our military taking over their land.

Anonymous picture
Taylor

If we are benefiting from putting our military base on their island then we should be doing more to help them with their poverty and disease. There is no reason why we can not help those people build cleaner and better homes and help with prevention of diseases. We moved them so we could have ...Read more

Anonymous picture
Tina

The juxtaposition of Ebeye and Kwajalein was extremely shocking and saddening. It seems inhumane and unfair for these people to undergo these living conditions for the US to just have a little bit of military practice.

Anonymous picture
Allison

We as Americans never go back to think the long term effects and try to look to the future for our nuclear warfare. I think its heartbreaking that a miscalculation lead to the destruction of health of innocent people. And tracked to be a living scientific study for the rest of their lives.

Anonymous picture
Clayton

I thought that the overall comparison between the U.S. and The Marshall Islands was shocking. The tuberculosis rate is 23 times greater than in the U.S. The fact that the U.S. played a role in this is very disheartening.

Anonymous picture
Dymon

It is shocking how unequal the Marshalls were treated. The fact that U.S Americans lived three miles in a nice suburb with a golf corse from theMArshalls, who were suffering. The Marshalls could not even live where they worked, they had to take a ferry. This is so sad to me. These people ...Read more

Anonymous picture
Carole

I had read a book several years ago titled "A Tidy Universe of Islands" about the Marshall Islands and the US nuclear testing in that area.
Watching this video just makes me furious how marginalized these people have been. It's just absolutely heartbreaking.

Anonymous picture
Krisha

I have learned about TB in microbiology, however it is always interesting to learn about the rates of TB and how so many people are infected with it, but only a certain number actually get the disease.

Anonymous picture
Brittny

I had never heard about this issue before watching this video. Overall I found it very interesting and so sad. I cannot believe that the US military caused this because of nuclear testing. The fact the TB is so common now clearly explains their lack of longevity. I really just cannot believe ...Read more

Anonymous picture
Sarah

As others mentioned, I was surprised at how high the TB rate was in Marshall. I understand that it is so high though because of how crowded houses and the area is. Any infectious disease would spread so much more rapidly in a compact area. Prevention measures must be a top priority to attempt ...Read more

Anonymous picture
Carson

Infectious diseases are easily spread because people are in contact with other people daily. Its terrible that this happened from our military. Very disappointing.

Anonymous picture
Trinaty

At the beginning of the video, it mentions how easily infectious diseases can spread. It makes sense because when people are constantly in contact and each home contains many individuals it just opens itself up to spread. I had never heard of these people and it is very upsetting to know it ...Read more

Anonymous picture
Suzan

This is just a heart breaking and a disappointment that the U.S. military is responsible to what happened to those people. I just cant imagine what hey had to go through and the lifestyle that they have. I don't even think that I have any words that would describe how bad i feel for them. ...Read more

Anonymous picture
Shaquayla

This video was very intense for me as I watched it. I cannot begin to imagine how this community feels. To know that their diseases that occurred recently were not their fault is what gets to me. The U.S. military is to blame due to the nuclear testing during World War II; thus caused for an ...Read more

Anonymous picture
Fatima

It is heart breaking the strong effects that poverty has not only on an individual but on a community as well. These people did not decide not their own to live like this and have a health problems, but if they were to have the appropriate resources then they could improve their health and ...Read more

Anonymous picture
Kelli

I've watched a few different videos in the past that expose the outcomes of US military presence in small countries. Eventually we cut off all of their resources to build our base and community and leave other communities to fend for themselves. In this episode, the US displaced people from ...Read more

Anonymous picture
Allysen

This episode was particularly disturbing for me. The Marshall Islanders are living in extreme poverty and with the high rates of tuberculosis, they are suffering from both communicable and non communicable diseases. Although the it is troubling to see the housing, or lack there of that the ...Read more

Anonymous picture
Courtney

I find it extremely shocking that Marshall has a TB rate is 23x that of the US. I agree with Julie Kroeker that the differences between the Ebeye and the US army base on Kwajalein is so vast and polar opposite between economic status and health. I was not aware that Bravo, a 15 megaton ...Read more

Anonymous picture
Waseem

The Marshalese Island has 23 x the rate of TB then of US. It is also an island who is an a very bad economic state and people are very crowded. This leads to a huge increase in disease suffered by the native population.

Anonymous picture
alexandrea

it is sad that TB is so high. poverty makes it so hard for them to stay healthy. With them living so close to each other, it will definitely make it spread faster since it can spread through the air.

Anonymous picture
Marissa

I was shocked to learn the overall rate of TB compared to the United States! This video was very eyeopening regarding the rates of infectious diseases in the Marshallese Island.

Anonymous picture
Tressa

This video really shows that even though many people carry a disease, your socioeconomic status can really effect if you actually acquire the disease. Its crazy how much more likely the Marshallese people are to acquire TB than people in the U.S.

Anonymous picture
Hannah

Sadly, I have never heard of the Marshall islands and the Marshallese people. Not in any history books, recent media, or even game show trivia has shed light on these people and their place of origin. I am aware of the increase and imperative knowledge pertaining to Tuberculosis, yet highly ...Read more

Anonymous picture
Breea

I had never heard anything about the Marshallese people, the nuclear war testing mishap, or about the Ronald Reagan Nuclear War testing center. I think this is another prime example of dislocation just like the video about the Indians. We American's were selfish in our ways and caused ...Read more

Anonymous picture
Brittany

I didn't know anything about this issue before watching this clip. I am sad that the Marshallese had to experience our issues at their expense but pleased to know that in the end, we have turned the situation around and offered some of these civilians more than the life they had on the ...Read more

Anonymous picture
Sierra

I was shocked to learn that TB is 23x more prevalent in the Marshall Islands. On average the Marshall islands live about 10 years less than the US. The Marshallese have taken a huge toll on their health when the US did nuclear testing on the island. They need a lot of help!

Anonymous picture
Ashliee

TB rates among the Marshallese are 23 times higher than in the States, and life expectancy for the Marshallese is substantially less than Americans?! What a scary thought!

Anonymous picture
Shana

The role the US plays in this video shows how politics can widen the gap and make health for one group worse. The US military created an even larger gap between Americans and Marshallese by overpowering the Marshallese, forcing them out of their homes and using their land for nuclear testing. ...Read more

Anonymous picture
Kori

The rates of disease in the Marshall is astounding. I could not believe that the TB rate there is 23x that of the United States.

Anonymous picture
Megan

This video opened up a new way of thinking about communicable diseases for me. I do wish that it would have gone into greater detail on how to combat those diseases for the Marshall Islanders. I am sure that immigration is not an answer for them all, and is not a perfect answer for any. It is ...Read more

Related videos

Not Just a Paycheck
Part of the Series: Unnatural Causes
In the winter of 2006, the Electrolux Corporation closed the largest refrigerator factory in the U.S. and moved it to Juarez, Mexico, for cheaper labor. The move turned the lives of nearly 3,000 workers in Greenville, Michigan, upside down. As middle-class Americans find their health and way of life increasingly…
Becoming American
Part of the Series: Unnatural Causes
Recent Mexican immigrants, although poorer, tend to be healthier than the average American. They have lower rates of death, heart disease, cancer, and other illnesses, despite being less educated, earning less and having the stress of adapting to a new country and a new language. In research circles, this is…
The Debt of Dictators
THE DEBT OF DICTATORS is the first film to expose the nefarious lending of billions of dollars by multinational banks and international financial institutions to brutal dictators throughout the world. Nobel Peace Prize Laureate, Adolfo Perez Esquivel, asserts that transnational banks "know the price of everything, but have no values".…
End of the Rainbow - The Impact of Global Extractive Industries
An in-depth look at the impact of a multinational gold mining industry on the economy, environment and traditions of a local community in Guinea. END OF THE RAINBOW provides a concise, in-depth look at the impact of global extractive industries on local populations, their economy, their traditions and their environment.…
Maquilapolis: City of Factories - Activism for Low-Wage Workers in Mexico
Part of the Series: Globalization
Carmen Duran works the graveyard shift in one of Tijuana's 800 maquiladoras; she is one of six million women around the world who labor for poverty wages in the factories of transnational corporations. After making television components all night, Carmen comes home to a dirt-floor shack she built out of…
May Justice Be Done - The Economic Crisis in Argentina
By any standard Argentina was a very rich country until the 1970s, with competitive industries, modern agriculture, and a prosperous middle class. By 2001, 21 out of 36 million people were living below the poverty level, and formerly eradicated diseases such as tuberculosis and leprosy reemerged. MAY JUSTICE BE DONE…
Health For Sale - The Debate Over Big Pharma
Are the world's largest drug companies, paradoxically, major obstacles to making a healthier world? HEALTH FOR SALE focuses on Big Pharma, the ten largest pharmaceutical makers, who account for 500 billion dollars of world health spending a year and whose 205 billion dollars in pre-tax profits were more than the…
Bad Sugar
Part of the Series: Unnatural Causes
The Pima and Tohono O'odham Indians of southern Arizona have arguably the highest diabetes rates in the world - half of all adults are afflicted. But a century ago, diabetes was virtually unknown here. Researchers have poked and prodded the Pima for decades in search of a biological - or…
When the Bough Breaks
Part of the Series: Unnatural Causes
The number of infants who die before their first birthday is much higher in the U.S. than in other countries. And, for African Americans, the rate is nearly twice as high than it is for white Americans. Even well-educated Black women have birth outcomes worse than white women who haven't…
Place Matters
Part of the Series: Unnatural Causes
Why is your street address such a good predictor of your health? Latino and Southeast Asian immigrants like Gwai Boonkeut have been moving into long-neglected urban neighborhoods such as those in Richmond, California, a predominantly Black city in the San Francisco Bay Area. Segregation and lack of access to jobs,…
In Sickness and in Wealth
Part of the Series: Unnatural Causes
What are the connections between healthy bodies, healthy bank accounts and skin colour? Our opening episode travels to Louisville, Kentucky, not to explore whether medical care cures us, but to see why we get sick in the first place, and why patterns of health and illness reflect underlying patterns of…
Unnatural Causes
UNNATURAL CAUSES sounds the alarm about the extent of our glaring socio-economic and racial inequities in health and searches for their root causes. But those causes are not what we might expect. While we pour more and more money into drugs, dietary supplements and new medical technologies, UNNATURAL CAUSES crisscrosses…